5 Reasons Why Arsenal Doesn’t Need to Sign Yoann Gourcuff

Yoann Miguel Gourcuff is a 25-year old French midfield playmaker that was touted as the next best thing in his Stade Rennais days from 2003 to 2006. He made a €4.5m move to AC Milan in the summer of 2006 but he was largely disappointing on and off the pitch in his San Siro days making 36 league appearances in three seasons.

A loan move to Laurent Blanc’s Girondins de Bordeaux in the 2008/09 season worked wonders for Gourcuff’s confidence. Gourcuff was so impressive in his loan stint at Bordeaux that was nominated for the FIFA Ballon D’ Or that year. He was also voted as Ligue 1’s Player of the Year and he deservedly made it into the Ligue 1 Team of the Year.

Bordeaux made the deal permanent after the loan spell only to sell him to French juggernauts Olympique Lyonnais for €22m a season after.

On the international scene, Gourcuff has represented France at every junior level and after earning his first French cap in 2008 against Sweden, he has gone on to make 28 caps for Les Bleus.

Yoann Gourcuff is a technically proficient and talented attacking midfielder that’s renowned for his eagle eye for a pass. He also has good dribbling skills as well as being a dead ball specialist. He has been admired a lot by Arsenal’s Arsene Wenger and he has been linked to the North London giants countless times.

Any team would certainly want a player of Gourcuff’s talents at their disposal but here are five reasons why Arsenal does not need to sign Yoann Gourcuff:

The Rise of Aaron Ramsey

Aaron Ramsey joined Arsenal from Cardiff in 2008 and was slowly introduced into the squad as there were many players above him in the pecking order. Ramsey ascended in the 2009/10 season and did well to shove off the threat of Abou Diaby and Denilson for a starting team berth but a career threatening injury suffered in February 2010 put a sudden halt in Ramsey’s progress.

This season Ramsey has gotten a lot of games under his belt and he has done well to put some impressive performances in some games while he has been mediocre in others. Ramsey’s learning curve is very steep and the introduction of Yoann Gourcuff will hinder his progress in the first team.

The Return to Fitness of Jack Wilshere

Jack Wilshere is undoubtedly one of the brightest talents England has produced in recent times and it took a loan move to Bolton Wanderers to unleash the beast within.

Wilshere was phenomenal for Arsenal last season and he duly won the Young Player of the Year in 2011. However, Wilshere played a lot of games last season and his fatigue played a part in the long-term ankle injury has suffered since August.

The Englishman is close to full fitness and he would seem like a new signing because he hasn’t played any football this season. Wilshere may not have immaculate passing ability Gourcuff possesses, but offers Arsenal a whole lot more.

Large Personnel in Midfield

Arsene Wenger employed the traditional 4-4-2 formation in his early days and was close to winning the title in the 2007/08 season before the club crumbled in grand style in the business end of the season. The blonde-haired Manuel Almunia had William Gallas and Kolo Toure in the heart of Arsenal’s defense while Bacary Sagna and Gael Clichy marauded the full-back positions.

Cesc Fabregas and Mathieu Flamini forged an extremely good understanding in the middle of the park while Tomas Rosicky and Aliaksandr Hleb were the terrorists of the flanks. Robin van Persie and Eduardo da Silva provided enough firepower for Emmanuel Adebayor that ended up scoring 30 goals that season despite Arsenal’s shortcomings.

Arsene Wenger kicked off the 2009/10 campaign with a new improved 4-2-3-1 formation that brought out the best in Fabregas but Wenger primarily used this new formation because of the large haul of midfielders in his disposal.

This season has been no different and Arsene Wenger has had the pleasure of a very large midfield to choose from, even though he hardly rotates them. With only 25 players registered for the ongoing season, Yoann Gourcuff can only come into the squad if a midfield player is flushed out- and that’s not happening anytime soon.

Large Transfer Fee

In Yoann Gourcuff’s career that has spanned through four clubs, his transfer fees keep increasing with each move.

Stade Rennias sold him to AC Milan for €4.5m and the Italian giants sold the playmaker to Girondins de Bordeaux for €13.5m. After two seasons with Bordeaux he made a €22m move to Olympique Lyonnais.

He is touted as one of the hottest properties in Europe thanks to his age and ability. He’s likely to command a mammoth fee to acquire his services from his current employers.

Arsene Wenger is a manager that likes making his signings in a shrewd manner and down the years, money has been an issue when it comes to sealing the deal for a player.

Arsenal has missed the likes of Franck Ribery, Xabi Alonso et al in the past and in recent times, Phil Jones and Juan Mata has missed out on wearing the Red and White because of a quid or two.

It’s fair to say that Yoann Gourcuff falls into that league.

Arsene Wenger Has Ruled Him Out

As the old adage goes, “No matter how much a child craves for sweets, If the Mother says no, he won’t get it.”

A faction of the Arsenal faithful would like to see Yoann Gourcuff wear the Red and White but the manager Arsene Wenger has ruled out a move for the playmaker according to ESPN Soccernet.

This clearly paints the picture for all Gooners that Yoann Gourcuff is not needed at Arsenal, for the time being at least.

Feel free to share your opinion in the comments section.


You can follow Gooner Daily on Twitter @goonerdaily. I’ll follow back

Feel free to visit Gooner Daily’s Facebook page and click on the like button.

You can also join Gooner Daily’s Mailing List to get notifications of new posts by email by clicking on the Follow button

Posted from WordPress for BlackBerry.

About enigma106

An Arsenal fan with a good sense of humor

Posted on January 6, 2012, in Arsenal, Football, Transfer Gossip and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink. 17 Comments.

  1. offiong onoyom

    I will always disagree with you that Ramsey is d reason Arsenal should not buy any good creative midfielder out there. Tell me dat we av got jack coming back and hopefully Diady but pls pls stop mentioning Ramsey bcos I’m yet to see anytng creative in him

    • You’ll have to cut Ramsey some slack. This bloke has massive potential and he can only harness it if he continues his run of games.

      Bringing in Gourcuff will hinder that

  2. i see no reason Y yohan can not be brought into the team pls let it be a competive team were only the best play for our dearling team DONT settle for less if a player can not fight for his own let him move on. compare Arsenal with the liks of Barca, Madrid and Man city.

    • You have a point though.

    • I totally agree witchu smiles….. We all like 2 settle 4 less @ arsenal…. Like check our defece 4 instance…bcos we alrdy hav Djoru and squlacci.. Wil make us nt 2 go 4 a player likecahil!! We need players like Cahil 2 increase competition in the heart of that defence..

      • Sad but true. Players like Djourou and Squillaci can’t command a first team place in teams of Arsenal’s calibre but they are fringe players that come in as cover ups for injuries.

        Djourou was Arsenal’s best defender last season and Squillaci has been shite

  3. Arsenal is not here to grow ramsey to his full potential… We want arsenal to win… If we have to stop ramsey to get a win den we have to do that… Arsenal’s win comes first.. Not ramsey fulfilling his potential… So thats a bad point i wud say… And he is not in a good form after his injury.. So his price is only gonna come down… Now wneger cud get him for a bargain..

    • I agree with you. As Arsenal fans, we want the best for our club but we have to come to terms with reality here. Aaron Ramsey is a player that will grow to be one of the best central midfielders in the Premier League so we have to give him that chance.

      Wilshere had such a chance and we both know what happened next.

  4. Wenger stop fooling gunners do buy podolski n build up awa defence we demand 4 trophies.

  5. lodu emmanuel lubang

    Lodu Emmanuel Lubang from South sudan appreciating Theo walcott, Robin Van persie and szczesny for there heart work in the club. we south sudanese encourage them to improved the club
    thanks you wenger

  6. i do agree with you enigma106, but u have to admit that there has been a spark that has been lost at the arsenal midfield, i have watched every arsenal game this season, and arsenal do need a creative, experienced spark to lift the club to new heights, the player i am talking about should be able to play fire with fire when needed, aswell as dominating the whole midfield at the same time, he should also be able to take shots from outside the box like a fierce lion and that is the quality arsenal lack at the moment, arsenal need a a midfield magician at the moment and i do agree with you that Gourcuff is not the answer. thankyou.

    • Fabregas is the all-spark of Arsenal and Nasri was also a great replacement down the middle.

      Since their departure, the burden of creativity has fallen to the likes of Aaron Ramsey but he hasn’t been super but he has been giving his all.

      That midfield magician is out waiting for Arsenal to make the move for him but Gourcuff will be one hell of a bargain.

  7. Too many people are suggesting selling deadwood and introducing world class players. This is not a manager mode on a game. Unless you are going to pay very high wages, ambitious players will not sit on the bench.

    I believe Ramsey is good but not world class which is what Arsenal need at the moment. He lacks consistency and the precision needed in his position. I see him as a backup to Wilshere or the frontman of the three in midfield.

    No one is sure about who Wilshere will replace. If he replaces Ramsey, he will be the main playmaker, something which he is not. The best bet would be

    Song (Holding) – Wilshere (Box-to-box)

    Back to Gourcuff, he can be world class. Plays a Zidane role but not as well as Zinedine. Can be compared to Kaka. A midfielder who can take the goalscoring burden off RvP by chipping in with a few goals.
    Overall, he should be bought and play in the starting eleven where i suggested Arteta plays. This purchase would show Arsenal mean business and i think £15m would be enough to secure it or £10-12m including one of the underperforming stars we have. Player and cash deal would mean he would take their place in the teamsheet of the 25 allowed.

    Let me know your thoughts, thanks for taking the time to read.


    • Great analysis IG, I believe that Ramsey will be relegated to the bench when Wilshere returns to full fitness. His arrival would mean that Arteta would be deployed behind the front 3 and I’m relishing in the prospect of seeing Arteta play the role.

      His goal against Wigan showed that he can let it rip from distance and we are no strangers to his good passing range.

      To Gourcuff, Arsenal will have to sell off Rosicky or Arshavin to accommodate the player. We also know that Lyon will play hardball over the player and Arsenal will be expected to pay a large sum to acquire his services.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.